← Back
Sabrina Yearwood · Real Estate

Your Long Island
Home Seller's
Guide

What to expect, what it costs, and how to walk away with the most money possible.

Licensed New York Real Estate Agent
A Note From Sabrina

"Selling your home is not just a transaction. For most people, it is one of the largest financial moves of their life."

I made this guide because sellers who understand the process make better decisions. They do not panic when an offer comes in lower than expected. They do not overprice their home and watch it sit. They know what to spend money on before listing and what to leave alone.

I work with sellers all across Long Island. This is what I walk every client through before we ever put a sign in the yard. Read it, save it, and reach out when you are ready to talk.

How Selling a Home on Long Island Actually Works

01
Know What Your Home Is Actually Worth

Before anything else, you need a realistic number. I do a full Comparative Market Analysis, which means looking at what similar homes in your area have actually sold for recently, not what people are asking, but what buyers are paying.

What you see on Zillow is an estimate, not an appraisal. Zestimates can be off by tens of thousands of dollars. A real CMA gives you a number grounded in actual market data.
02
Prepare Your Home to Sell

Small things make a real difference. I walk through your home before we list and tell you honestly what is worth addressing and what is not worth spending money on. The goal is to maximize your return, not spend unnecessarily.

The highest-return updates are usually the ones that cost the least: deep cleaning, fresh neutral paint, decluttering, and improving curb appeal. Buyers decide how they feel about a home within the first 30 seconds.
03
Price It Right From the Start

Overpricing is the single biggest mistake sellers make. A home that sits too long starts to feel like something is wrong with it, even when there is not. Pricing it correctly from day one attracts more buyers, creates competition, and often leads to a better final number than overpricing ever would.

On Long Island, well-priced homes in good condition routinely receive multiple offers. Buyers are watching the market closely and they know when something is priced right.
04
Professional Photos and Marketing

Most buyers find homes on their phones before they ever walk through a door. Professional photography is not optional. It is the difference between someone scheduling a showing and scrolling past. I handle the marketing strategy, online listings, and outreach so your home gets in front of the right buyers.

Homes with professional photos sell faster and for more money. This is not a place to cut corners.
05
Showings and Open Houses

Once your home is listed, buyers will schedule private showings and you may choose to host open houses. The more accessible you make your home, the more exposure it gets. Try to keep it clean and easy to show, especially in the first two weeks when activity is highest.

Sellers who are flexible about showing times sell faster. The buyer who is perfect for your home might only be available on a Tuesday afternoon.
06
Review Offers and Negotiate

When offers come in, I help you evaluate every detail, not just the price. Contingencies, financing type, down payment amount, and proposed closing date all affect how strong an offer actually is. A lower offer with fewer contingencies can sometimes be worth more than a high offer with a lot of conditions attached.

In New York, sellers are not obligated to respond to any offer. We strategize together before you respond to anything.
07
Contract, Inspection, and Attorney Review

Once you accept an offer, the buyer will schedule a home inspection. Issues found during inspection can be used to renegotiate. Your attorney reviews the contract, handles the title, and protects your interests through closing. You will need your own attorney, and I can refer you to people I trust.

Do not panic during inspection. Almost every home has findings. What matters is how you respond and what is actually worth negotiating over.
08
Appraisal and Mortgage Approval

If the buyer is getting a mortgage, the bank orders an appraisal. The home must appraise at or above the purchase price. If it does not, you may need to renegotiate the price or the buyer may need to cover the difference in cash.

Pricing your home correctly from the start reduces the risk of an appraisal gap becoming a problem at this stage.
09
Closing Day

Before closing, the buyer does a final walkthrough to confirm the home is in the agreed condition. On closing day, both sides sign paperwork, funds are transferred, and you hand over the keys. Your net proceeds are wired to you typically the same day.

Make sure utilities are transferred and any agreed repairs are completed before closing day. Surprises at the table can delay everything.

What Actually Affects Your Sale Price

📍
Location and School District

The single biggest factor. Two homes that look identical can sell for very different prices based on the zip code alone. School district reputation drives significant price differences on Long Island.

📐
Size and Layout

Square footage matters, but so does how the space is used. A well-laid-out smaller home can outperform a poorly designed larger one. Open floor plans and functional kitchens are especially valued.

🏠
Condition and Updates

Updated kitchens, bathrooms, and mechanicals (roof, HVAC, hot water heater) have the most impact. Buyers will discount a home that needs work, often more aggressively than the actual cost to fix it.

📈
Current Market Conditions

A seller's market with low inventory works in your favor. A buyer's market with lots of competition means pricing strategy matters even more. I keep you informed on what is happening right now, not six months ago.

📸
Presentation and Marketing

How your home is photographed, described, and marketed directly affects how many buyers see it and how quickly offers come in. This is one area where having the right agent makes a measurable difference.

What Selling Costs You

Sellers often focus on what they will receive and forget to account for what comes out first. Here is a realistic breakdown.

Cost
Typical Amount
Agent Commission
Split between listing and buyer's agent
4% to 6%
Attorney Fee
Required in New York
$1,500 to $3,000
NY Transfer Tax
Paid by seller in New York
0.4% of sale price
Mansion Tax (if applicable)
Homes sold over $1 million
1%+
Pre-Listing Repairs or Updates
Depends on condition of home
Varies
Prorated Property Taxes
Settled at closing
Varies
Moving Costs
Plan for this early
$1,000 to $5,000+

Straight Answers

How long will it take to sell my home?

A well-priced home in good condition on Long Island can go into contract within days to a few weeks. Homes that sit longer are usually overpriced or have a condition issue that needs to be addressed.

Do I need to make repairs before listing?

Not always. It depends on the condition of your home and your goals. I walk through with you and give you an honest opinion on what will actually move the needle versus what is unnecessary spending. Some sellers list as-is and price accordingly.

Should I be home during showings?

No. Buyers are much more comfortable exploring and talking openly when the seller is not present. Make it easy for them to picture themselves in the space.

What if I get a lowball offer?

We counter. A lowball offer is not an insult, it is a starting point. I help you respond strategically so we either get to a number that works or move on without wasting time.

What will I actually walk away with?

I walk every seller through a full net sheet before we list. That means you know exactly what to expect after agent commissions, attorney fees, taxes, and any outstanding mortgage balance, before you ever accept an offer.

Is now a good time to sell on Long Island?

Long Island has seen consistently low inventory for years, which generally favors sellers. But your specific neighborhood, home condition, and personal timing all matter. I give you a real answer based on your situation, not a generic one.

Free Consultation

Curious what your
home is worth?

Let's talk through your timeline, your goals, and what you can realistically expect in today's market. No pressure, no obligation.

Message Me on Instagram
(631) 949-1705

Town of Babylon · Long Island, NY